Pencils

Make writing a little more fun with our hand-stamped pencils from Natty Michelle Paperie! Whether you’re jotting down notes, making lists, or doodling ideas, these charming, high-quality pencils add personality to your desk. Each set features funny, motivational, or custom phrases, making them perfect for students, teachers, writers, and stationery lovers alike

46 products

46 products

Sold Out
Athens Hometown Red and Black Pencil Set
Athens Hometown Red and Black Pencil Set
$8.00
Quick view
Athens is for Lovers Pencils
Athens is for Lovers Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Athens, Georgia Hometown Pencil Set
Athens, Georgia Hometown Pencil Set
$8.00
Quick view
Atlanta Empire State of the South Pencils
Atlanta Empire State of the South Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Be The Sunshine Pencils
Be The Sunshine Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Bloom Where Life Plants You Pencils
Bloom Where Life Plants You Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
from $6.00
Quick view
Bunco Night Pencils | 4th Of July
Bunco Night Pencils | 4th Of July
from $6.00
Quick view
Bunco Night Pencils | Christmas
Bunco Night Pencils | Christmas
from $6.00
Quick view
Bunco Night Pencils | Fall
Bunco Night Pencils | Fall
from $6.00
Quick view
Bunco Night Pencils | Halloween
Bunco Night Pencils | Halloween
from $6.00
Quick view
Bunco Night Pencils | Spring and Summer
Bunco Night Pencils | Spring and Summer
from $6.00
Quick view
Bunco Night Pencils | St. Patrick's Day
Bunco Night Pencils | St. Patrick's Day
from $6.00
Quick view
Bunco Night Pencils | Valentine's Day
Bunco Night Pencils | Valentine's Day
from $6.00
Quick view
Change the World Girl Pencils
Change the World Girl Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Charleston Hometown Pencil Set
Charleston Hometown Pencil Set
$8.00
Quick view
Cheers to the Glory Days Pencils
Cheers to the Glory Days Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Do What You Love Pencils
Do What You Love Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Every Day is a Fresh Start Pencils
Every Day is a Fresh Start Pencils
from $2.00
Sold Out
Feminist Pencils
Feminist Pencils
$2.00
Quick view
Find the Good in Each Day Pencils
Find the Good in Each Day Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Friendship Pencils
Friendship Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Good Things Are Coming Pencils
Good Things Are Coming Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Grow through what you go through Pencils
Grow through what you go through Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Home is Where the Arch Is Pencils
Home is Where the Arch Is Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Hope Blooms Pencils
Hope Blooms Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
In Darkness, there is Light Pencils
In Darkness, there is Light Pencils
from $2.00
Quick view
Keep Going Pencils
Keep Going Pencils
from $2.00
Athens is for Lovers Pencils
Athens is for Lovers Pencils
Athens is for Lovers Pencils
Athens is for Lovers Pencils
Athens is for Lovers Pencils
Athens is for Lovers Pencils
Athens is for Lovers Pencils
Athens is for Lovers Pencils

Athens is for Lovers Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
The pencil set perfect for anyone who loves The Classic City

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• White pencil with red foil stamped lettering
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Athens, Georgia Hometown Pencil Set
Athens, Georgia Hometown Pencil Set
Athens, Georgia Hometown Pencil Set
Athens, Georgia Hometown Pencil Set
Athens, Georgia Hometown Pencil Set
Athens, Georgia Hometown Pencil Set

Athens, Georgia Hometown Pencil Set

$8.00 Save $-8.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
5 city landmarks that make Athens special! Packaged loosely.

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Natural wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Stamped with gold foil lettering
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Atlanta Empire State of the South Pencils
Atlanta Empire State of the South Pencils
Atlanta Empire State of the South Pencils
Atlanta Empire State of the South Pencils

Atlanta Empire State of the South Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Atlanta: The Empire State of the South

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Black hexagonal barrel
• White stamped lettering
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Be The Sunshine Pencils
Be The Sunshine Pencils
Be The Sunshine Pencils
Be The Sunshine Pencils

Be The Sunshine Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Pastel yellow with gold foil lettering
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Bloom Where Life Plants You Pencils
Bloom Where Life Plants You Pencils
Bloom Where Life Plants You Pencils
Bloom Where Life Plants You Pencils

Bloom Where Life Plants You Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Bloom where you are planted! Makes a great gift for anyone who's embarking on a new life adventure.

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Green hexagonal barrel
• White stamped lettering
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils
Bunco Night Pencils

Bunco Night Pencils

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
It's Bunco night! These pencil sets are sold in sets of three in the following designs:

WHAT TABLE DO I GO TO? | IT'S BUNCO NIGHT! | WHAT NUMBER ARE WE ON?

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Packaged loosely in sets of 3
Bunco Night Pencils | 4th Of July
Bunco Night Pencils | 4th Of July
Bunco Night Pencils | 4th Of July
Bunco Night Pencils | 4th Of July

Bunco Night Pencils | 4th Of July

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

It's Bunco night! These pencil sets are sold in sets of three in the following designs:

WHAT TABLE DO I GO TO? | IT'S BUNCO NIGHT! | WHAT NUMBER ARE WE ON?

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Packaged loosely

Bunco Night Pencils | Christmas

Bunco Night Pencils | Christmas

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

It's Bunco night! These pencil sets are sold in sets of three in the following designs:

WHAT TABLE DO I GO TO? | IT'S BUNCO NIGHT! | WHAT NUMBER ARE WE ON?

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Packaged loosely

Bunco Night Pencils | Fall
Bunco Night Pencils | Fall
Bunco Night Pencils | Fall
Bunco Night Pencils | Fall

Bunco Night Pencils | Fall

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

It's Bunco night! These pencil sets are sold in sets of three in the following designs:

WHAT TABLE DO I GO TO? | IT'S BUNCO NIGHT! | WHAT NUMBER ARE WE ON?

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Packaged loosely

Bunco Night Pencils | Halloween
Bunco Night Pencils | Halloween
Bunco Night Pencils | Halloween
Bunco Night Pencils | Halloween
Bunco Night Pencils | Halloween
Bunco Night Pencils | Halloween
Bunco Night Pencils | Halloween
Bunco Night Pencils | Halloween

Bunco Night Pencils | Halloween

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

It's Bunco night! These pencil sets are sold in sets of three in the following designs:

WHAT TABLE DO I GO TO? | IT'S BUNCO NIGHT! | WHAT NUMBER ARE WE ON?

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Packaged loosely

Bunco Night Pencils | Spring and Summer
Bunco Night Pencils | Spring and Summer
Bunco Night Pencils | Spring and Summer
Bunco Night Pencils | Spring and Summer

Bunco Night Pencils | Spring and Summer

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

It's Bunco night! These pencil sets are sold in sets of three in the following designs:

WHAT TABLE DO I GO TO? | IT'S BUNCO NIGHT! | WHAT NUMBER ARE WE ON?

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Packaged loosely

Bunco Night Pencils | St. Patrick's Day
Bunco Night Pencils | St. Patrick's Day
Bunco Night Pencils | St. Patrick's Day
Bunco Night Pencils | St. Patrick's Day

Bunco Night Pencils | St. Patrick's Day

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

It's Bunco night! These pencil sets are sold in sets of three in the following designs:

WHAT TABLE DO I GO TO? | IT'S BUNCO NIGHT! | WHAT NUMBER ARE WE ON?

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Packaged loosely

Bunco Night Pencils | Valentine's Day
Bunco Night Pencils | Valentine's Day
Bunco Night Pencils | Valentine's Day
Bunco Night Pencils | Valentine's Day

Bunco Night Pencils | Valentine's Day

$6.00 Save $-6.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

It's Bunco night! These pencil sets are sold in sets of three in the following designs:

WHAT TABLE DO I GO TO? | IT'S BUNCO NIGHT! | WHAT NUMBER ARE WE ON?

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Packaged loosely

Change the World Girl Pencils
Change the World Girl Pencils
Change the World Girl Pencils
Change the World Girl Pencils

Change the World Girl Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Pencils for the feminist with a to-do list.

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Black hexagonal barrel
• White stamped lettering
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Charleston Hometown Pencil Set
Charleston Hometown Pencil Set
Charleston Hometown Pencil Set
Charleston Hometown Pencil Set
Charleston Hometown Pencil Set
Charleston Hometown Pencil Set
Charleston Hometown Pencil Set
Charleston Hometown Pencil Set

Charleston Hometown Pencil Set

$8.00 Save $-8.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
5 city landmarks that make Charleston special:

FORT SUMTER | WATERFRONT PARK | HISTORIC KING STREET | CITY MARKET | RAINBOW ROW

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Packaged loosely
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Natural wood pencil with gold foil lettering
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Cheers to the Glory Days Pencils
Cheers to the Glory Days Pencils
Cheers to the Glory Days Pencils
Cheers to the Glory Days Pencils
Cheers to the Glory Days Pencils
Cheers to the Glory Days Pencils

Cheers to the Glory Days Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with white eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Red pencil with black stamped lettering
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Do What You Love Pencils
Do What You Love Pencils
Do What You Love Pencils
Do What You Love Pencils
Do What You Love Pencils
Do What You Love Pencils

Do What You Love Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
The pencil set perfect for anyone who loves (and maybe misses) The Classic City

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Red pencil with white stamped lettering
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Every Day is a Fresh Start Pencils
Every Day is a Fresh Start Pencils
Every Day is a Fresh Start Pencils
Every Day is a Fresh Start Pencils

Every Day is a Fresh Start Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Pastel yellow with gold foil lettering
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Find the Good in Each Day Pencils
Find the Good in Each Day Pencils
Find the Good in Each Day Pencils
Find the Good in Each Day Pencils
Find the Good in Each Day Pencils
Find the Good in Each Day Pencils

Find the Good in Each Day Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Find the good in each day

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Pink hexagonal barrel
• White stamped lettering
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Friendship Pencils
Friendship Pencils
Friendship Pencils
Friendship Pencils
Friendship Pencils
Friendship Pencils

Friendship Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Friendship is the purest love

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Lilac hexagonal barrel
• White stamped lettering
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Good Things Are Coming Pencils
Good Things Are Coming Pencils
Good Things Are Coming Pencils
Good Things Are Coming Pencils
Good Things Are Coming Pencils
Good Things Are Coming Pencils

Good Things Are Coming Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Good things are coming!

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Gold hexagonal barrel
• White stamped lettering
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Grow through what you go through Pencils
Grow through what you go through Pencils
Grow through what you go through Pencils
Grow through what you go through Pencils
Grow through what you go through Pencils
Grow through what you go through Pencils
Grow through what you go through Pencils
Grow through what you go through Pencils

Grow through what you go through Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Grow through what you go through

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Green hexagonal barrel
• White stamped lettering
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Home is Where the Arch Is Pencils
Home is Where the Arch Is Pencils
Home is Where the Arch Is Pencils
Home is Where the Arch Is Pencils
Home is Where the Arch Is Pencils
Home is Where the Arch Is Pencils

Home is Where the Arch Is Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
The pencil set perfect for anyone who loves The Classic City!

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Hexagonal barrel
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Red pencil with black lettering
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
Hope Blooms Pencils
Hope Blooms Pencils
Hope Blooms Pencils
Hope Blooms Pencils
Hope Blooms Pencils
Hope Blooms Pencils

Hope Blooms Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.
Where flowers bloom, so does hope

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Lavender hexagonal barrel
• White stamped lettering
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers
In Darkness, there is Light Pencils
In Darkness, there is Light Pencils
In Darkness, there is Light Pencils
In Darkness, there is Light Pencils
In Darkness, there is Light Pencils
In Darkness, there is Light Pencils

In Darkness, there is Light Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Pencils for the feminist with a to-do list.

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Black hexagonal barrel
• White stamped lettering
• Classic gold ferrule with black eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers

Keep Going Pencils
Keep Going Pencils
Keep Going Pencils
Keep Going Pencils

Keep Going Pencils

$2.00 Save $-2.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

You've Come So Far. Keep Going.

• 7" long
• Unsharpened
• Black hexagonal barrel
• Gold foil stamped lettering
• Classic gold ferrule with pink eraser
• Wood case pencils with No. 2 lead
• Certified non-toxic
• Latex-free synthetic erasers